In today’s fast developing world where everything is going global; lingual, cultural and regional boundaries are still operative in India which is a country with a plurality of culture and language. In this scenario, translation of regional literature into English, a target language that is common among the heterogeneous linguistic communities is a step towards dissolving these boundaries and painting a common national ethos. Saadat Hasan Manto is a well-known short story writer of Indian subcontinent. His Urdu short stories have been translated into many languages. His story “Toba Tek Singh” is considered a masterpiece. It has been translated into English by different translators. The present paper attempts a comparative study of these English translations and tries to evaluate the merit and authenticity of these translations.